An Italian politician has set off a political storm in India by criticizing democracy in the world’s most populous nation, touching a raw nerve in a country that was under British colonial rule for nearly two centuries.
Indian political parties, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s BJP, accused the opposition Congress Party of allowing foreigners into India’s domestic political debate, while government sources told RT India that the secretary general of the Italian Party of European Socialists (PES), Giacomo Filibeck, violated his visa terms by interfering in domestic Indian issues.
Filibeck on Saturday repeated a slogan often used by Indian opposition leader Rahul Gandhi against the Modi government and the election commission that is responsible for holding elections in the world’s largest democracy.
“Vote chor, gaddi chhod,” Filibeck told an audience at an event where he shared the stage with Gandhi in the southern city of Hyderabad. He then translated the slogan into English, saying, “vote thief, leave your seat,” as Gandhi applauded.
Filibeck also said, “democracy is under attack in India, and we need to defend it.”
The Indian opposition has been protesting against a voter roll revision underway in the country that has led to the deletion of millions of names from voting lists. They allege that the deletions will help tilt elections in favor of the BJP. The poll panel denies favoring any political party, and maintains that the revision is intended to remove duplicate and ineligible entries.
“Have you ever seen anyone laughing when India is insulted by a foreigner?” Modi’s parliamentary affairs minister, Kiren Rijiju, asked on X, referring to Gandhi.
The Indian government has not officially reacted to Filibeck’s remarks but sources told RT India that Filibeck came on a conference visa that he had applied for through the e-visa portal. “Foreigners are not supposed to interfere in domestic politics, whatever visa they may be on. By doing so, one is flouting visa rules,” the source said.
BJP sources said the party will approach the Foreigners Registration Office about the issue. A leader of the regional BRS party, Karthik Reddy Patolla, called it “treason” to let foreign leaders mock Indian democracy. The BRS is not an ally of the BJP.
Filibeck also took flak from Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s Forza Italia party. “As Europeans, we consider it inappropriate to give lessons on democracy to a country that has 970 million citizens voting,” a lawmaker from the party, Deborah Bergamini, posted on Facebook.
“It is inappropriate to intervene in the domestic political debates of a major friendly nation – a country with which Italy has established a ‘special strategic partnership’, fostering deep cooperation across all sectors,” she added.